knob template: scroll down list of users

timeless timeless at myrealbox.com
Fri Jun 10 22:57:42 UTC 2005


Greg Hendricks wrote:
> Just as a note of interest, we tried implementing this a while back and 
> quickly decided it was not a good idea for a couple reasons:
> 2) if you have a large number of users then you have to download the entire 
> user list for every bug you view. In our case it was a significant slow down 
> on the page.

forget huge list. my company has ~30 people, unfortunately most of them 
have names that begin (some names are changed to similar English names 
to simplify my example) with J (jim, john, josh), S (sam, scott, sharon) 
and T (terry, tim, tom). As such, using autocomplete works a lot better 
than the listbox (in fact there are usually ~5 people per letter and i 
usually want the middle one). As the list grows beyond 30 things get 
considerably worse, you get more collisions and you're always better 
served by any form of completion or nicknaming. Browsers especially 
mozilla tend to behave terribly with any form of a list like this.



More information about the developers mailing list